| Lon Gordon * (about 1871) |
| P.M. Piercy * |
| George Tarrant * |
| J.A. Hukel * |
| Benjamin J. Forbes * |
| George Johnson ** |
| Amos Bennett |
| E.E. Phillips |
| S.G. Anthony |
| Joseph A. King |
| Phillip Theodore Dunning |
| William Russell |
| Phillip Theodore Dunning |
| Samuel Albert Moore |
| Aubrey Winston Berry |
| Wallace Price |
| Nelson Eichmann |
| * | Early administrators were identified as Principal rather than Superintendent |
| ** | First identified Superintendent and uncle of President Lyndon Baines Johnson |